There’s something so hopelessly romantic about falling for your bother’s best friend. It’s a supreme romance book trope—he’s the guy who witnessed your awkward phases growing up and teased you, the guy who feels somehow off-limits even though he’s always around, or maybe he’s the kind of guy you know you should stay away from. Think secret crushes, protective family members, and forbidden love.
Readers love that kind of tension. Maybe the characters start as friends—who knows, maybe even adversaries—but their relationship blossoms into something more. And what I love most about this trope is the built-in history that has us yearning for the two love interests to get together. There is a lot of longing with this trope, which is why it’s one I’m always happy to pick up.
So if you’re looking for the best brother’s best friend romance novels, you’ve come to the right place! Here are the books that you’ll want to add to your TBR.
What is the Brother’s Best Friend Trope?
The brother’s best friend trope shows up in a variety of ways in romance books, so every story you pick up will be a little different. Here are some common themes you might find, though:
A little sister who always had a crush on her older brother’s friend growing up, even though he didn’t seem to notice her
A guy who considers his best friend’s sister as off-limits, but he struggles to resist her
An LGBTQIA+ story where a male character has a crush on his brother’s guy friend
People who knew each other as kids in passing, and then reconnect on a deeper level as adults
Secret relationships to keep it from the brother/best friend in question
Protective brothers and complicated friendships or family dynamics
I’m personally always a fan of a Male Main Character (MMC) who secretly pines away for the Female Main Character (FMC). I’m a sucker when we find out that the brother’s best friend always had a thing for her but didn’t yet have the courage to act on it!
Why We Love the Brother’s Best Friend Trope
Finding love is one of the greatest feelings in the world—people go to great lengths to meet their soulmate! But there’s something poetic about a person finding love with somebody who’s always been around. Maybe they’ve seen us through good and bad times, through heartbreaks, and through puberty. But then there comes a day when they look at us a little differently…
Aside from that kind of emotional appeal, falling in love with brothers best friend books can weave in elements of forbidden love, years of pining and unresolved feelings that make it a wonderful slow burn, or forced proximity that keeps the characters close. The primary trope might be brother’s best friend, but a whole slew of other tropes means that no two books feel exactly the same.
There’s also the built-in conflict that tears the characters in two—do they remain loyal to their family member, or do they follow their heart?
12 of the Best Brother’s Best Friend Romance Books
The Long Way Home by Liv Arnett
For the last four years, Rachel has spent her time becoming exactly who everyone needs her to be, but when she walks into her best friend’s wedding and locks eyes with Rhett, her carefully constructed world starts to fracture. Choosing him means dismantling the life she’s so carefully constructed. This is a small-town, slow-burn romance that will tug at your heartstrings.
Tropesick by Lauren Okie
This is such a clever magical realism romance with the brother’s best friend trope. In this contemporary romance, two childhood neighbors with a heartbreaking shared history reunite to ghostwrite a romance novel for a mysterious author. But as they spend the summer together at a secluded Hamptons estate, the romance tropes they’re writing about begin unfolding in their own lives, blurring the lines between fiction and reality.
Watch Your Mouth by Kandi Steiner
Grace knows her brother’s hockey teammates are strictly off-limits, but that only makes tempting the brooding Jaxson Brittain even more irresistible. After one steamy night turns into something much harder to ignore, an unexpected road trip throws them together again. Miles away from all the reminders of why they shouldn’t get closer, it makes their chemistry impossible to ignore. This is perfect if you love the forced proximity of a road trip romance!
Match Made in the Maldives by Theresa Christine
Luna is determined to enjoy her family’s dream vacation in the Maldives, even while hiding the fact that her business is struggling and her relationship has fallen apart. But a tropical getaway with family means her brother’s best friend—who is practically family, too—joins, and their attraction makes a peaceful getaway in paradise way more complicated. This is a brother’s best friend romance books free for newsletter subscribers, FYI!
In Your Dreams by Sarah Adams
After her culinary career in New York crashes and burns, Madison returns to her hometown for a fresh start and accepts a job running a new farm-to-table restaurant. The only issue? Her new boss is her brother’s best friend, James, a man who’s been secretly in love with her for years. As they work together to bring the restaurant to life, keeping their relationship strictly professional becomes easier said than done.
Lucky Penny by Katherine Bitner
Second chance romance lovers, this one’s for you. Ten years ago, they were inseparable—until she left for college and he went to prison. Penny returns to her hometown to help her younger sister and discovers that her ex, Jesse, is living under the same roof. With painful memories, unfinished business, and an attraction that refuses to disappear, their unexpected reunion is the second chance neither of them saw coming.
Play with Me by Becka Mack
This is some readers’ holy grail of brother’s best friend romance books, and for good reason. It combines the excitement of a hockey romance with a walking, talking green flag book boyfriend. Hockey player Garrett Andersen knows he needs to stay away from his captain’s younger sister, Jennie, but resisting her is easier said than done—especially when they end up living next door to each other. What starts as a casual arrangement quickly turns into something more… 😉
Forbidden to Fall by Martha Keys
Sadie has spent her life pretending she never had a crush on her brother’s former best friend, but James’s unexpected return to the small town of Autumn Ridge digs those buried feelings right up. Working together at his family’s farm forces them together, even as the town's judgment and her brother’s lingering resentment threaten their romance. You can obviously read this anytime, but it’s perfect for fall vibes.
Reunions and Ruses by Marie Landry
Brother’s best friend + fake dating = match made in trope heaven. After a failed marriage and a string of setbacks, Stella returns to her hometown feeling like a complete failure. When she convinces her brother’s best friend, Leland, to pretend to be her boyfriend at a high school reunion, their fake relationship might just become the one thing in her life that feels unexpectedly right.
A False Start by Elsie Silver
Age gap lovers, pay attention! This is such a great setup. When Griffin shares a passionate kiss with a beautiful stranger, he has no idea she’s Nadia, his best friend’s younger sister. With fourteen years and a complicated past standing between them, Griffin knows she’s completely off-limits, but staying away becomes increasingly difficult as their undeniable attraction grows.
If Only You by Chloe Liese
This is a fun twist on the fake dating trope—fake friendship! Professional soccer player Ziggy Bergman is tired of being treated like the innocent baby of the family, while bad-boy hockey player Sebastian Gauthier desperately needs to repair his reputation. So what better thing to do than fake a friendship? But as they spend more and more time together, they discover a connection neither of them expected.
Because of Us by Nina Arada
This emotional romance will take you on a roller coaster, and the past and present chapters let us see the relationship develop between Josie and Wes. Josie never forgot the unforgettable summer she spent falling in love with Wes, her twin brother’s best friend, or the terrible heartbreak that followed. Seven years later, she’s back in town and facing the man who was once her everything. But giving their love another chance means deciding whether she can trust him with her whole heart again.
Frequently Asked Questions About Brother’s Best Friend Romance Books
Do brother's best friend romances always involve a childhood crush?
Not always! In brother’s best friend romance books, high school years are sometimes part of the story, or at least the history. But it’s very much dependent on the book, the characters, and at what age they know each other first. I think with teenagers, there is sometimes a crush simmering in the background, since the characters are really just becoming adults and battling those raging hormones. But it’s not a requirement for this trope.
Are brother’s best friend spicy romance books or closed door?
They certainly can be, but it’s not a requirement. Romance books vary in spice level, and looking through blurbs, reviews, and content warnings will let you know if a book is closed-door or not.
What is the difference between brother’s best friend and best friend’s brother romance?
Good question! These are very similar tropes but there’s an important distinction here. The brother’s best friend trope implies that the main character has a brother, and the romance is with the brother’s friend. With best friend’s brother, this means that the main character is friends with someone who has a brother, and the romance is with him. You’ll get similar vibes, but they’re not interchangeable tropes.
What’s the difference between the brother’s best friend trope and the best friend’s little sister romance books?
Also a good question, and I’d say that these are describing the same thing, just from different character’s POV. In romance books with a male and female protagonist, maybe even told in Dual Point of View, the “brother’s best friend” would refer to the FMC’s perspective, while the “best friend’s little sister” refers to the MMC’s perspective. Obviously these can be used for romances between to male or two female characters, I’m just letting you know what I’ve encountered most commonly!
Does the brother always disapprove of the relationship?
An overprotective brother who doesn’t approve of the relationship—even though he’s okay with being friends with the MMC—is a bit of a tired way the trope plays out, if you ask me. I personally think this works better in historical romances, which are set in time periods where women were not given full autonomy over their lives. You’ll still see unhappy brothers discovering a relationship between their sibling and best friend in contemporary romances, but it’s not a must, and I’d venture to say the discovery can play out in a more nuanced way!
Can there be MM brother’s best friend romances between two men?
Yes, absolutely! I don’t have any in this list because I typically read MF romances, so that’s what I can confidently recommend. But it’s absolutely a trope for queer love stories, too.
Can a brother's best friend romance also be enemies to lovers?
Absolutely. Think about it: you’re thirteen, wearing dorky braces, and a huge Kpop fan, and when your brother’s best friend comes over, they tease you relentlessly. Having that dynamic can be really fun, because we get to witness the change between the two characters as they go from disliking each other to the opposite.
Are there brother’s best friend romance books with happy endings?
Yup! All the books in this list have a Happy Ever After (HEA). It’s actually the only genre requirement for romance books, and as a romance author and reader, I would never lead you astray with a romance book that doesn’t have an HEA!
No matter how many romance books I read, the brother’s best friend trope will never, ever get old. There’s just something I love about those simmering feelings, and how the characters seem to know so much more about each other before things turn romantic. Hopefully you enjoyed this list and found some great books to add to your TBR! If you want to find more book recommendations, check out my book recs blog posts or join my newsletter for more great recs and book deals delivered straight to your inbox.