Why I Love Writing Characters Who Don’t Have it All Together

Nothing brings me greater joy than writing characters who are a little bit of a mess.

As nice as it is to imagine a character whose life is all figured out and perfect, you have to admit, that’s not particularly compelling to read. Part of the reason I read and write romance books is because we get to see the journey that a character goes on. If they’ve already got everything sorted at the top of the book, then they don’t really have anywhere interesting to go.

There’s a frequent discussion that I see in the book world that revolves around relatability to and likability of a character. We want to read characters we can root for, right? But I have to wonder, what, exactly, makes us not like a character or not see ourselves in them? Honestly, when a character is flawed or makes mistakes, I think that readers sometimes want to put a distance between themselves and what they see in that character. But we all have parts of ourselves that are less than perfect, and we don’t have to wait until we are perfect in order to give and receive love. We are completely and totally lovable, even if our life is a little chaotic or we don’t always make the best choices—and the same goes for our fictional characters, too!

It’s way more enjoyable as an author to write characters who have somewhere they can aspire to be. Maybe they’re not the best with decision-making, perhaps they’re the kind of person who hangs on to emotional baggage way too long, maybe they’ve got career problems, or they could just be in denial that their life actually is the train wreck that they’re convincing themselves it’s not. But just as perfection is overrated in real life, it’s overrated in fiction, too. You would lose interest really quickly, promise. And yes, a person who has flaws, who is contradictory, or has insecurities can sometimes be a frustrating person to follow—but those are all very human traits.

As I’m writing a first draft and figuring out really who my characters are at their heart, I will sometimes discover things about them that contradict what I thought I knew about them or what I had set up in my mind for the book. For instance, in my debut novel, The Half of It, I knew that I wanted June, the main character, to reluctantly be going to Ireland to meet her half sister. But then I had to ask myself, why would she even go if she really didn’t want to meet this person? This is where the story got to be a little bit interesting, and I had to develop it even further than my original idea. June wasn’t just going to meet her half sister; she was also going for her job. Not only that, but it’s a job that is not really ideal, so she’s very much hoping that everything will work out so that she can get a promotion.

I’m also very much drawn to female main characters who put on a front of being composed and put together, but who feel very differently inside. That’s one of the really rewarding things about writing in first-person point of view…I get to explore the interior life of a character, which includes their fears and anxieties, but then I craft the way that they present themselves to the world. If you think about it, you’re not always forthcoming with your own emotions. For example, when you’re scared about presenting something at work, you probably don’t go to your boss and say, “I’m scared.” You put on a brave face, despite the storm inside yourself. That is a really fun and exciting place to explore as an author.

Luna from Match Made in the Maldives is a great example of this. She’s been cheated on by her boyfriend, and her graphic design endeavors aren’t exactly thriving. But she pretends that everything is just peachy for her family vacation, not wanting to upset anyone or bring the mood down.

I also have to admit, I love characters who are still figuring themselves out. I think that part of this comes from perpetually feeling like a teenager in a 30-something-year-old’s body. It took me a while to figure out my own path, and I still battle vulnerability and insecurities some days. Growing up, I excelled in a lot of different subjects in school. But that also meant that for a long time in my life, I felt very unmoored. I was good at a lot of different things, but not necessarily great at any one thing. So, naturally, I like writing characters who have their own complicated self-discovery journeys.

I think the main character, Daisy, from my book In a Desert Daze, is the best example of this. Daisy struggled in school and wasn’t really sure what she wanted to do for a career. Then, with her mother’s passing, she decides to take over a hotel or risk losing that part of her mother forever. Running The Mirage hotel was not necessarily Daisy’s calling, and she certainly was never trained to do that job. It’s a lot of learning for her, and a lot of stumbling, too. A big part of her journey in that book is figuring out what her place is in the world, not just in relation to the hotel, but in relation to the kind of career she wants to have.

But beyond entertainment, writing messy, imperfect characters is really important to show readers that they do not have to be perfect in order to be deserving of love. Anyone can have a love story, even when the world is burning. Even when they’ve just been fired or made a mistake or when nothing seems to be going their way. And it’s not to say that love will magically fix their lives. Romance doesn’t swoop in and magically erase a person’s insecurities, fears, and mistakes.

And this is why I personally don’t ever want my books to be perfectly tied up in a bow at the end. I write romance books, which means there’s a guaranteed happy ever after, or HEA. But a happy ending doesn’t mean that life has to be perfect by the end. The characters may have overcome many of their problems, but they will still have issues in the future that they will have to face. And that’s honestly incredibly romantic, isn’t it? Finding someone who will love you and weather the storm alongside you.

Those super messy moments are some of the most chaotic but enjoyable to write. Often, when I’m writing and trying to figure out how to work my way through a conflict for a character, I will ask myself, “What is the absolute worst thing that could happen to them in this moment?” And then I choose whatever that answer is. (I know, I’m not particularly nice to my characters, but they do thank me by the end) Those kinds of writer choices don’t make the writing process easy, but they do make it complex and exciting. I really put my characters through the wringer to the point where, when they come out on top of this, you feel like they have more than earned their happy ending.

In an early draft of Match Made in the Maldives, I wrote a scene near the end of the book that made it very easy for the two love interests, Luna and Finley, to avoid the attention of Luna’s family. It was an easy ending, but my critique partners encouraged me to make this scene more challenging, and more worth it. They wanted to see the messy bits. They wanted to see everything fall apart and completely implode before these characters then had to turn around, put in the work, and achieve a resolution. It meant that I had to dig in and write an uncomfortable, very honest section of dialogue that revealed some not-so-pretty parts of my main characters. But I’m so glad that I did this, because it makes their ending even more satisfying.

Because I write contemporary romances that I want to feel very real, flaws and imperfection and messiness are all part of the game. That’s just life. Nobody has everything figured out all the time, including me. And I personally find comfort in writing stories where people are allowed to be a work in progress, because that is me: a walking, talking work in progress. So I guess that’s why I relate to the kind of characters that I typically like to write, because I embrace that messiness is a part of who I am and that is a part of a life. It’s what makes me human.

So here’s to the beautifully messy characters who deserve love no matter what. May we know them, may we be them, may we read them.

Next
Next

The Best Brother’s Best Friend Romance Books that will Have You Swooning